While I usually make my brother birthday cookies of the cartoon characters he most loves at the moment (this is his 38th birthday, by the way), I decided this time to stick with the classics. We’ve been making smiley cookies on a stick for a decade. (The “we” here refers to the shop where I worked for nearly a decade, Bundles of Cookies. I still say “we” though I left to have my daughter over a year ago, because I was such an integral part of the shop for so long. Sigh. Will always be “we” to me.) Hundreds, nay, thousands of designs we’ve done, but the classic smiley-on-a-stick’s popularity has endured all these years. The instructions here are rather different than those we make at the store. And as always, the stick is optional, but it’s this lollipop phase I’m in.
how to make a smiley cookie on a stick
you will need:
circle cookie cutters (I used 2 1/2″ and 1 1/2″)
lollipop sticks (optional)
Americolor soft gel pastes (any, I used Egg Yellow, Electric Green, Orange)
Americolor black gourmet writer
1 frosting bag, coupler and rubber band for each color
1 size “4″ tip for each color
small spoon or squeeze bottle
small knife or spatula
*Find the cutters, sticks, parchment, bags, couplers, and tips at any major craft store. You will also find colors and writers at craft stores, but I just love Americolor best. Americolor products are available online or at many specialty cake decorating stores.
step one: bake your cookies
Roll your dough pretty thick to accommodate the sticks (about 1/4″). Cut out your circles and lay on a parchment paper-lined baking tray. Insert sticks about half way into the cookie. Bake according to the recipe and let cool.
step two: frost your cookies
Tint a cup (or more if you make a lot of cookies) of frosting to the desired shade. Prepare a frosting bag with size 4 tip. Fill with about 1/2 cup of the frosting and close tightly with a rubber band. Pipe an outline on the circle cookies. Let set about 20 minutes. Thin the rest of the frosting until syrupy, with 1/4 tsp. water at a time. Using a spoon or squeeze bottle, pour frosting into center of cookie and spread carefully to edges with a small spatula or knife. Let set well, at least 2 hours, more if possible.
Feel free to share (nicely)! While my blog's photographs and text are protected by copyright, I do allow (and encourage) you to share ONE photograph with credit to "the decorated cookie" and link to this blog post. PLEASE don't reprint any part of the blog post and PLEASE don't post a photo without credit. Thank you!