popsicles that never melt (because they are cookies)

OK, so if you left these cookies sitting outside in the 90 plus degree heatwave we are enduring, they would likely be affected. But much more slowly.

How to make “popsicle” cookies:

you will need:*
food coloring
decorating bags
decorating tips, size “4”
rubber bands
popsicle sticks

sharp knife

popsicle template

*Find disposable decorating bags, the tips, couplers and popsicle sticks in the craft store. For food coloring, I prefer Americolor soft gel pastes. Choose any colors you like. I used Red, Orange, Electric Green, Regal Purple and Bright White (for the highlight, you can also use a lighter version of the popsicle color in lieu of white). You’ll need one bag, tip, coupler and rubber band per color plus extra decorating bags. For tips on finding food coloring, click HERE. For the popsicle template, CLICK HERE. You can also use a tombstone or popsicle cookie cutter if you have one, and cut off the bottom.
step one: bake your cookies
Roll out chilled cookie dough about 1/4 inch thick (thick enough to accommodate sticks). Cut out the popsicle template, lay on the dough, and cut out with a sharp knife. Pat edges of cookie to smooth. Place on parchment paper-lined baking tray and insert popsicle stick about half way into cookie so the stick is fully inside the cookie (no stick should be seen poking out the back). Bake according to recipe and let cool. Note: I had no problem cooking the sticks in the oven, and I assume most brands are the same. But I don’t know if every brand will work as swimmingly, so please stick by the oven just in case! I can’t imagine they’d burst into flames, but I wouldn’t want such a thing on my conscious!step two: prepare your frosting
Prepare frosting and tint in desired colors, about 1 cup for each popsicle color (you may use less for the highlight color. I made some white frosting to use as my highlight color.) Prepare frosting bags with couplers and size 4 tips and fill with about half of your prepared colors and one with the white frosting. Tie closed tightly with a rubber band.step three: decorate your popsicles
Outline popsicles with a color of frosting. Let set about 15 minutes. Thin reserved frosting of the same color with water, a few drops at a time, until the consistency of thick glue. Put the thinned frosting in an empty frosting bag, close off the top, and snip about 1/8 inch from the tip. Loosely pipe thinned frosting over the cookie and let flood to edges, encouraging as needed with a toothpick or the back of a spoon. Let set well, a couple hours, before piping a highlight on top.

Feel free to share (nicely)! While my blog's photographs and text are protected by copyright, I do allow (and encourage) you to share ONE photograph with credit to "the decorated cookie" and link to this blog post. PLEASE don't reprint any part of the blog post and PLEASE don't post a photo without credit. Thank you!


  1. Domestic Sugar says

    You always do such a nice job explaining the technique!
    Love the colours too!

  2. Anita Kehn says

    These are darling! I've never made popsicle cookies but I have made soapcicles! (popsicles made out of soap)

  3. Teresa says

    Cute! Cute!
    Well….beyond CUTE!
    Frosted sugar cookies that look like THAT are perfection!
    Maybe…just maybe…it will be that easy for me one day!
    Love your BLOG!
    Such a great resource!
    And I do believe I need your BOOK!

  4. Sue Sparks says

    I love these; they're adorable! I even have the popsicle sticks on hand! Can't wait to make them…how can I pass up popsicles that don't melt?!? :)

  5. bridget {bake at 350} says

    So, so cute! These would be SO much better than a REAL popsicle. I mean, who even needs one of those when you can have THESE?!?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *